Dreamies Vs. Temptations Cat Treats Comparison

Disclaimer: Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links; we will earn a commision, at no additional cost to you, if you make a purchase through one of our links.

If you’re a cat lover, a cataholic, or an ailurophile, you’ve probably come across at least one of these brands: Dreamies and Temptations—two of the most known cat treat brands in the global market.

Yes, we know, they look undeniably the same!

In this Dreamies vs. Temptations show-off, we’ll finally dig into the question that most cat owners have thought of:

Are Dreamies and Temptations the same?  

Dreamies vs. Temptations in a Nutshell

Dreamies and Temptation Treats are both cat treats brands manufactured by Mars Petcare. They look identical in terms of packaging, physical appearance, flavor variants, and product specifications.

The key difference between these brands is the product varieties they offer. Dreamies has a few types of product variants, while Temptations offers a wide range of feline treats.

Aside from that, the geographic availability of these two brands also differs. Dreamies is widely available in the UK, and some parts of Europe and Asia, while Temptations is marketed across the USA and some neighboring countries.



  • Vitamins and Minerals
  • Crunchy outside soft inside
  • Less than 2 calories per piece.


  • 100% nutritionally complete
  • Balanced for adult maintenance.
  • Crunchy on the outside, soft on the inside.
  • Under 2 calories per piece.

Dreamies: A Quick Overview

DREAMIES Chicken Cat Treats 60 g (Pack of 8)

Dreamies is a cat treat brand manufactured by Mars, Incorporated, a multinational business giant in the food and pet care industry. This product line is readily available all over the UK and across other countries.

The brand’s Classic Treats is a pillow-shaped snack that has a unique crunchy texture on the outside with a soft savory filling inside. It’s brilliantly formulated to capture the taste and carnivorous cravings of your feline companions—making it addictive and irresistible to them.

Dreamies’ line of products is primarily made from meat and vegetable by-products as well as fats. Their treats also contain protein extracts, cereals, and minerals that make each snack even more nutri-packed. Moreover, the brand claims that each treat contains less than two calories only.

Product Highlights

  • Marketed across the UK and other parts of Europe and Asia
  • Formulated to attract the natural palate and aromatic instincts of cats
  • Helps with cat training and mental stimulation
  • Priced competitively to fit all types of consumers

Temptations: A Quick Overview

TEMPTATIONS Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Tasty Chicken Flavor, 30 oz. Tub (Packaging May Vary)

Temptations Treats is a brand of cat treats manufactured by Mars Petcare, a subsidiary of Mars, Incorporated. Their line of products is manufactured and marketed across the USA. Temptations also offers a variety of product variants that come in various flavors and textures.

Primarily, they market savory flavors and mixed-flavor variants for their Classic Treats. Then, years after, the brand launched more product variants, such as oral care bites, kitten treats, and creamy purees.

Product Highlights:

  • Claims to be 100% nutritionally complete
  • Meets the AAFCO Cat food Nutrient Profiles’ nutritional standards
  • Marketed across the UK and other parts of Europe and Asia
  • Offers a wide variety of unique product variants
  • Formulated to attract the natural palate and aromatic instincts of cats
  • Helps with cat training and mental stimulation

Related: Greenies vs. Temptations full cat treat comparison

Dreamies vs. Temptations: The Uncanny Resemblance

Even from a glance, you can easily tell that these two products have a lot in common.


From the packaging to its marketing strategies, Dreamies and Temptations are like two peas in a pod.

First, let’s talk about the most obvious part: the packaging. From the colors to the fonts and images used, these brands’ packaging visuals are undeniably identical. Well, this isn’t a surprise since the same manufacturer makes them.

Now, peeking through their market strategy, you might notice that they also market the same trademark— “All it takes is a shake.” This catchline is often rephrased by both brands in most advertisements they launch as individual labels.

Astonishingly, with that same trademark, both brands became famous to every happy feline consumer for the “shake effect” of their treats.

Product Specifications

You guessed right, these two brands essentially highlight the same type of product. Both brands market pillow-like, bite-sized treats with a unique crunchy shell filled with a creamy, savory filling.

Both brands offer the same variety of flavors and sizes of cat treats, too. They market their products as appealing to cats’ natural tastes and preferences—with less than two calories per treat.

Similar Flavors

Despite having differing variant names, these two brands offer the same type of flavors, which are: beef, chicken, salmon, tuna, turkey, cheese, and catnip. Both also offer mix-up variants that are a hit to many.

Dreamies vs. Temptations: Their Subtle Differences

Product Variety

Dreamies and Temptations both highlight the same classic variants. However, they individually offer unique types of products fit for every picky feline the world can feed.

Product variants offered by Dreamies:

  • Classic Cat Treats
  • Mix-Ups
  • Meaty Sticks
  • Stocking Adult Treats (Seasonal)

Product variants offered by Temptations:

  • Classic Cat Treats
  • Mix-Ups
  • Meaty Bites
  • Shake Ups
  • Temptations Kitten
  • Oral Care Dentabites

Target Market and Availability

Despite being manufactured by the same company, Dreamies and Temptations were launched in two different countries—targeting different market segments.

Temptations Treats was launched and is manufactured in the USA, targeting a wide range of customers across the country. On the other hand, Dreamies is manufactured in the UK and is widely offered to other neighboring counties as well.

Hence, the product availability of these brands differs depending on your geographic location.

Which One Should You Buy?

When it comes to cat treats, Dreamies and Temptations are two of the most trusted brands on the global market. Both offer a wide variety of flavors and textures to please even the pickiest of felines. But which one is the better choice for your cat?

If you stayed throughout our analysis, you should know by now that there’s just a subtle difference between the two brands—so why not try both, right?

Users Also Read: Luvsome Cat Food Review

You (but mostly your cat) can have the best of both worlds. However, note that your geographic location might restrict you from getting these brands’ awesome products.

The good thing is, since we’re now living in a globalized world, getting these two products on your hands isn’t relatively impossible. Try surfing the internet and find online platforms or shops near you (or your country) that offer these goodies and compare these two amazing brands firsthand.

May you find the purr-fect match for your special one!