Temptations Vs. Greenies Full Comparison

Disclaimer: Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links; we will earn a commision, at no additional cost to you, if you make a purchase through one of our links.

When it comes to feeding our furry friends, we want to make sure we’re giving them the best. That said, with so many brands and variants available on the market, choosing the right product can be a challenge.

Today, we’ll have a side-to-side comparison of two popular pet snack brands: Temptations vs. Greenies.

In this article, we’ll dive into the details of each brand to help you decide which is the best fit for your feline companion.

Temptations vs. Greenies in a Nutshell

Temptations and Greenies are both pet treats brands manufactured by Mars Petcare. However, their product line features different uses, serving diverse types of consumers and demands.

The key difference between these brands lies in their product specifications, product varieties, target market, and availability.

Temptations offer a wider variety of flavors—perfect for all felines, including picky eaters. Greenies, on the other hand, target oral problems and the general health of your furry friends, which is a huge plus for your cat pantry.

<meta charset="utf-8">Temptations


  • High-quality ingredients
  • Delicious and nutritionally balanced
  • Includes a wider variety of flavors
<meta charset="utf-8">Greenies


  • Targets oral problems
  • Includes Dental Treats, SmartBites & Pill Pockets

Temptations: A Quick Overview

Temptations Treats is a brand of cat treats manufactured by Mars Petcare. These treats have a unique shape and texture that’s intentionally developed to satisfy feline natural taste preferences.

Above all, their products are made with a combination of high-quality ingredients and various nutrient content that make cat snacks both delicious and nutritionally balanced.

Due to popular demand, the original Classic Treats product line has since expanded to include other variations, such as oral care bites, kitten treats, and creamy purees—perfect for all types and ages of feline.

Greenies: A Quick Overview

Greenies is a popular pet treat brand for both dogs and felines. It’s also established by Mars Petcare and manufactured in the USA. The brand’s known for its revolutionary “Greenies Dental Treats”.

In its first few years, Greenies solely marketed treats specialized for dogs. Eventually, due to the product’s popularity and success, the brand developed “Feline Greenies.”

Feline Greenies is a line of cat treat products designed to promote oral and general health in cats. This line includes Dental Treats, Pill Pockets, and Smartbites.

The brand precisely formulated their products with specific nutrients and natural ingredients. These essential components help control tartar, plaque buildup, and freshen the breath of your feline friends. The treats are also shaped to clean teeth and massage gums as your cat chews.

Feline Greenies are widely available in various flavors across the USA, UK, and other parts of the globe.

Save 35% on All Pet Supplies from Chewy
You will also get $20 off your first order on Chewy (plus free shipping). I personally think Chewy provides the best prices and offers, especially when it comes to my regular pet supply needs.

Similarity Check

First, let’s quickly look at some of these two brands’ common denominators.

Specific Product Variants

Classic Treats

These two brands offer a common type of product among their product line: “Greenies Smartbites” and “Temptations Classic Treats”.

These two similar products are pillow-shaped treats made crunchy on the outside with a soft flavorful filling inside. These remarkable treats are available in a variety of fun flavors.

Kitten Treats

Temptations and Greenies also manufacture a variant specially developed for kittens’ dietary needs.

Oral Care

Both brands offer a product variant specially made for cats’ oral health. Greenies Dental Treats and Temptations Dentabites help keep your cat’s teeth and gums healthy.

Flavor Variants

Despite having differing variant names, some of the flavors offered by these brands are typically the same. The two brands include chicken, salmon, and other similar flavors among their product options.

Readers also liked: Weruva Low Phosphorus cat food review

The Ultimate Comparison

Now, moving on to the highlight of the show, let’s take a closer look at the differences between these two popular brands.

TEMPTATIONS MIXUPS Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Backyard Cookout Flavor, 30 oz. Tub

Product Variety

Temptations focus on products that’ll satisfy every feline taste buds that exist. The brand offers a wide range of flavors, textures, and variants so you can find the perfect fit for your cat.

Let’s have a look at their wide range of products below.

Temptations’ Product Variants

  • Classic Cat Treats
  • Mix-Ups
  • Meaty Bites
  • Shake Ups
  • Temptations Kitten
  • Dentabites
  • Seasonal Variants

Greenies, on the other hand, focus on our feline friends’ dental and healthcare necessities.

The brand specially developed their products to target specific cat health needs. Their products promote good dental, digestion, skin, and fur condition of cats.

Here are their feline products that you can choose from.

Feline Greenies’ Product Variants:

  • Dental Treats
  • Pill Pockets
  • Smartbites: Healthy Indoor
  • Smartbites: Skin and Fur Health
  • Smartbites: Healthy Kitten

Nutrient Content

Now, it’s time to look at the back of the packaging—the nutrient content.

To fairly compare the two brands, let’s dig into the nutritional facts of their similar products.

Temptations Dentabites vs. Greenies Dental Treats

Looking at this close comparison, Temptations Dentabites have slightly more fat, protein, and calorie content than Greenies.

Temptations Classic Treats vs. Greenies Smartbites

When it comes to their classic treats, Greenies contain a little more fat and fiber content, while Temptations have a bit more protein, moisture, and calories.

Related: Supreme Source cat food review

Target Market and Intended Use


Temptations is a famous cat treat brand known for its addictive taste for cats. The brand targets cat owners looking for a tasty treat that makes their furry friends rave with joy.

It’s widely available in different variants—crunchy, soft, chewy, and puree. In addition, temptations allow you to choose a treat suitable for your cat’s age, size, and chewing habits.

Furthermore, they target cat owners that want to improve training. That’s because Temptations can improve cats’ mental stimulation.

Feline Greenies

Greenies Feline SMARTBITES Skin & Fur Crunchy and Soft Textured Adult Natural Cat Treats, Salmon Flavor, 16 oz. Tub

Feline Greenies, on the other hand, target specific health demands of cats. Their revolutionary product called “Dental Treats” is known for its effectiveness in maintaining a cat’s oral health.

Moreover, Greenies offers solutions to those owners who find it hard to give pills to their fur babies. In addition to this, the brand also launched supplements for feline skin, fur, and general health.

Which One Should You Buy?

When it comes to cat treats, Temptations and Greenies might be your top options. These two trusted brands both offer high-value products. If you’re still unsure, let’s wrap up the key takeaways of our analysis as a guide for your informed decision.

Generally speaking, both brands are great treats for your cats. However, each brand offers different product variants and markets different purposes.

Temptations offer a wide variety of flavors and textures, which is perfect for felines who are still exploring their preferences—even for kittens and picky eaters. The varieties offered by the brand are also ideal for cat training and mental stimulation.

Alternatively, if you have concerns with your cat’s oral health and skin/fur condition—but don’t want to let go of that “addictive” taste, you might want to try Greenies products and see what your fur baby approves of.

Purr-haps, just try both brands and give your cat the best of both worlds.